(This post is being published as part of Scenes of the Crime blogathon under sub genre Mysteries and Thrillers. The last movie of one of the greatest American directors Sidney Lumet, a dark, brilliantly shot thriller, with a non linear narration. And featuring top notch performances by Philip Seymour Hoffman, Ethan Hawke, Albert Finney)
May your glass be ever full,
May the roof over your head be always strong,
And may you be in heaven
Half an hour before the devil knows youāre dead.- Irish Drinking Toast
SidneyĀ LumetāsĀ Ā BeforeĀ TheĀ DevilĀ KnowsĀ YouĀ areĀ Dead,Ā startsĀ offĀ straightĀ withĀ a steamy scene, thatĀ hasĀ theĀ heroineĀ GinaĀ Hanson( MarisaĀ Tomei) being done byĀ herĀ husband, Andy Hanson(Ā PhillipeĀ SeymourĀ Hoffman).Ā ItĀ doesĀ lookĀ a bitĀ incongruousĀ toĀ seeĀ theĀ ratherĀ gorgeousĀ lookingĀ GinaĀ being doneĀ in by the pot bellied, pudgyĀ looking Andy, making youĀ feelĀ howĀ sheĀ endedĀ upĀ withĀ him.Ā Ā Yep while itĀ can beĀ disconcerting toĀ watchĀ HoffmanāsĀ bare behind,Ā Ā Ms. TomeiāsĀ fullĀ MontyĀ more thanĀ makesĀ upĀ forĀ it. The coupleĀ has aĀ postĀ sexĀ talk in one of thoseĀ typicalĀ L-ShapedĀ sheets, we get to see in HollywoodĀ movies.Ā As the ratherĀ inconsequentialĀ scene, fadesĀ away,Ā thatĀ isĀ whereĀ weĀ come to the movieāsĀ Ā criticalĀ scene,Ā orĀ theĀ plotĀ point, aroundĀ whichĀ the entireĀ movieĀ revolves.Ā Ā Ā We onlyĀ know aĀ robberyĀ isĀ going to be comitted,Ā andĀ Ā soon enoughĀ Ā aĀ maskedĀ intruderĀ holds up a jeweleryĀ and diamondĀ store.Ā DuringĀ theĀ hold up, a shoot outĀ occursĀ between an elderly lady, theĀ storeĀ owner,Ā andĀ theĀ robber, with the latter beingĀ shotĀ fatallyĀ dead, whileĀ theĀ ladyĀ isĀ critically injured.
SidneyĀ Lumet takesĀ theĀ robberyĀ asĀ theĀ main plot deviceĀ to keep going to and fro, in a narrativeĀ thatĀ isĀ non linear, asĀ theĀ charactersĀ andĀ theĀ motivationsĀ comeĀ slowlyĀ into theĀ frame.Ā Ā Ok firstĀ thingsĀ first, BeforeĀ The Devil Knows You areĀ Dead isĀ notĀ anĀ easyĀ watch,Ā atĀ any stretch.Ā Ā WhileĀ theĀ narrativeĀ doesĀ goĀ aroundĀ inĀ a non linearĀ fashion,Ā it isĀ easyĀ toĀ follow,Ā Ā itĀ isĀ notĀ muchĀ ofĀ a mind bender,Ā asĀ Ā theĀ characterāsĀ motivationsĀ becomeĀ quiteĀ apparent.Ā ThereĀ areĀ noĀ bigĀ twistsĀ atĀ anyĀ stage,Ā asĀ everythingĀ doesĀ proceedĀ onĀ conventionalĀ lines,Ā andĀ evenĀ theĀ ending while beingĀ a shockerĀ isĀ notĀ a surprise,Ā itĀ wasĀ somethingĀ oneĀ couldĀ Ā seeĀ coming,Ā ifĀ we keep trackĀ ofĀ theĀ characters.Ā Ā TheĀ hardĀ partĀ in watchingĀ itĀ is howeverĀ theĀ dark,Ā despairingĀ mood,Ā andĀ theĀ utterlyĀ unsympatheticĀ characters.Ā Ā TheĀ moodĀ isĀ cynicalĀ throughout,Ā offering noĀ hopesĀ forĀ redemption,Ā andĀ add to it aĀ slowĀ pace,Ā Ā with silences,Ā thatĀ canĀ quiteĀ oftenĀ suffocateĀ theĀ viewer.Ā Ā ButĀ onceĀ youĀ are preparedĀ toĀ handleĀ the dark moodĀ ofĀ theĀ movie,Ā whatĀ youĀ getĀ toĀ seeĀ is aĀ masterpiece.
ForĀ closeĀ toĀ 5Ā decades,Ā SidneyĀ Lumet hasĀ beenĀ makingĀ someĀ ofĀ theĀ greatest moviesĀ ever.Ā RogerĀ Ebert callsĀ him aĀ ānationalĀ treasureā,Ā Ā nowĀ whileĀ thatĀ isĀ forĀ theĀ AmericansĀ toĀ decide,Ā iĀ haveĀ noĀ hesitation in callingĀ LumetĀ aĀ cinematicĀ treasure,Ā wordsĀ likeĀ genius,Ā maestro,Ā auteurĀ doĀ notĀ reallyĀ doĀ justiceĀ toĀ thisĀ brilliantĀ movie maker.Ā Ā HeĀ isĀ the directorĀ whoĀ createdĀ some ofĀ theĀ finestĀ legalĀ dramas,Ā 12Ā AngryĀ Men, The Verdict,Ā Ā brilliant cop dramasĀ likeĀ Serpico,Ā Q&A,Ā Ā crimeĀ dramasĀ likeĀ DogĀ DayĀ Afternoon,Ā Anderson Tapes,Ā Ā Ā orĀ dark satiresĀ like Network.Ā Ā ButĀ whereĀ LumetĀ scoresĀ bigĀ timeĀ isĀ inĀ hisĀ characterization,Ā theĀ charactersĀ inĀ hisĀ moviesĀ areĀ fleshedĀ outĀ soĀ wonderfully. LikeĀ a masterĀ sculptor,Ā heĀ chiselsĀ outĀ everyĀ feature, everyĀ partĀ ofĀ theĀ character withĀ suchĀ lovingĀ detail,Ā rightĀ down toĀ theĀ warts, andĀ like anĀ expertĀ pyschiatrist,Ā heĀ delvesĀ deep into theĀ mind ofĀ his characters,Ā readingĀ them,Ā decodingĀ theirĀ motivations,Ā andĀ thenĀ settingĀ upĀ theĀ relationshipsĀ between them.Ā LumetāsĀ strengthĀ hasĀ beenĀ theĀ humanĀ personaĀ and the dramaĀ revolvingĀ aroundĀ peopleāsĀ actions.Ā More oftenĀ thanĀ not,Ā hisĀ moviesĀ workĀ on aĀ characterĀ intending toĀ performĀ anĀ action,Ā andĀ theĀ resultĀ endingĀ upĀ something moreĀ thanĀ whatĀ theyĀ imaginedĀ for.
In a wayĀ BeforeĀ TheĀ DevilĀ KnowsĀ You AreĀ Dead,Ā referencesĀ backĀ toĀ LumetāsĀ earlierĀ DogĀ DayĀ Afternoon, whereĀ AlĀ PacinoāsĀ Ā botchedĀ upĀ bank robbery , spiralsĀ intoĀ eventsĀ thatĀ goĀ outĀ ofĀ control.Ā TheĀ storeĀ hold upĀ andĀ theĀ subsequentĀ shootĀ outĀ thatĀ leadsĀ toĀ theĀ fatalĀ injuryĀ to the elderlyĀ lady,Ā isĀ whatĀ setsĀ inĀ motionĀ a seriesĀ ofĀ events,Ā whichĀ wasĀ notĀ whatĀ wasĀ intended toĀ happen.Ā TheĀ criticallyĀ injuredĀ ladyĀ atĀ theĀ storeĀ happensĀ to beĀ NanetteĀ Hanson,Ā theĀ motherĀ ofĀ Ā Andy andĀ hisĀ brother HankĀ Hanson( Ethan Hawke).Ā TheĀ key here isĀ thatĀ theĀ entireĀ storeĀ robberyĀ wasĀ AndyāsĀ ownĀ baby,Ā andĀ thatĀ isĀ whereĀ the characterāsĀ motivationsĀ comeĀ intoĀ picture.Ā WhatĀ LumetĀ hasĀ doneĀ hereĀ isĀ toĀ pickĀ upĀ elementsĀ ofĀ theĀ noir, heistĀ genre,Ā andĀ setĀ itĀ against a dysfunctionalĀ family backdrop.
TheĀ onlyĀ charactersĀ whoĀ areĀ normalĀ andĀ likableĀ inĀ theĀ movieĀ isĀ theirĀ fatherĀ CharlieĀ Hanson( Albert Finney),Ā and his wifeĀ Nanette.Ā Ā InĀ factĀ LumetĀ hereĀ isĀ clearlyĀ contrastingĀ theĀ lovingĀ relation betweenĀ CharlieĀ and his wife, withĀ theĀ moreĀ messedĀ upĀ livesĀ ofĀ AndyĀ andĀ Hank.
The thing about real estate accounting is that you can, you can, add down the page or across the page and everything works out. Everyday, everything adds up. The, the total is always the sum of its parts. Itās, uh, clean. Itās clear. Neat, absolute. But my life, it, uh, it doesnāt add up. It, uhā¦ Nothing connects to anything else. Itās, uhā¦ Iām not, Iām not the sum of my parts. All my parts donāt add up to oneā¦ to one me, I guess.
OnĀ theĀ surfaceĀ ofĀ it,Ā AndyĀ appearsĀ normal, heĀ hasĀ a niceĀ job,Ā a niceĀ apartment, aĀ beautifulĀ trophyĀ wife,Ā andĀ managesĀ toĀ make it outĀ toĀ regularĀ vacationsĀ abroad,Ā inĀ shortĀ livingĀ theĀ AmericanĀ dream.Ā Ā BeyondĀ the surface thoughĀ howeverĀ itĀ isĀ oneĀ largeĀ mess,Ā Ā heĀ hasĀ beenĀ embezzlingĀ moneyĀ fromĀ hisĀ companyāsĀ accountĀ toĀ finance hisĀ cocaineĀ habit,Ā theĀ auditorsĀ areĀ Ā hotĀ onĀ hisĀ heels.Ā AndyĀ yearnsĀ forĀ hisĀ fatherāsĀ love, whom he feels doesĀ not understand him.Ā AndĀ toĀ makeĀ Ā mattersĀ worse,Ā hisĀ wifeĀ Gina,Ā feelingĀ repressedĀ carriesĀ on anĀ affair withĀ hisĀ brotherĀ Hank.Ā InĀ shortĀ AndyĀ hatesĀ hisĀ ownĀ life,Ā andĀ itĀ isĀ clearĀ thatĀ GinaĀ forĀ all theĀ humping on andĀ the lovey doveyĀ talkĀ in theĀ starting,Ā Ā isĀ notĀ tooĀ happy either.
HankĀ on theĀ otherĀ hand,Ā doesĀ notĀ evenĀ Ā have aĀ pretenseĀ to looking good.Ā Ā He is divorced, Ā owesĀ aĀ largeĀ amountĀ ofĀ moneyĀ to hisĀ exĀ wifeĀ Ā Martha ( AmyĀ Ryan),Ā Ā Ā whom heĀ has to payĀ forĀ Ā childĀ support, and lives in a broken downĀ home.Ā Ā Ā HeĀ isĀ so down onĀ hisĀ luck,Ā thatĀ heĀ doesĀ notĀ even haveĀ the money toĀ payĀ forĀ hisĀ daughterāsĀ school outing toĀ seeĀ TheĀ LionĀ King,Ā promptingĀ herĀ to callĀ himĀ aĀ loser.Ā Ā AndyĀ whileĀ outwardlyĀ successfulĀ isĀ as much as a loserĀ asĀ HanksĀ is.Ā Ā Ā It is justĀ thatĀ heĀ happensĀ to beĀ moreĀ smarterĀ andĀ moreĀ devious.
But little Mouse, you are not alone,
In proving foresight may be vain:
The best laid schemes of mice and men
Go often askew,
And leave us nothing but grief and pain,
For promised joy!- RobertĀ Burns
Again notĀ sureĀ ifĀ SidneyĀ LumetĀ hasĀ everĀ readĀ Burns,Ā orĀ beenĀ inspiredĀ byĀ him,Ā butĀ thisĀ particularĀ coupletĀ sums upĀ theĀ mainĀ theme.Ā Ā Ā AndyĀ makesĀ upĀ whatĀ heĀ believesĀ is aĀ Ā perfectĀ plan,Ā Ā toĀ robĀ hisĀ parentsĀ JewelryĀ store,Ā andĀ thenĀ Ā splitĀ theĀ moneyĀ up.Ā Ā Ā HisĀ reasoningĀ isĀ basedĀ onĀ whatĀ heĀ āthinksāĀ areĀ theĀ conditions,Ā atĀ theĀ Ā time ofĀ the heist,Ā onlyĀ theĀ oldĀ ladyĀ DorisĀ wouldĀ beĀ there,Ā noĀ real gunsĀ wouldĀ beĀ used,Ā Ā andĀ add toĀ it, theĀ storeĀ isĀ insured, soĀ hisĀ parentsĀ doĀ notĀ Ā reallyĀ loseĀ anything.Ā InĀ essence,Ā AndyĀ believesĀ heĀ hasĀ plottedĀ outĀ theĀ perfectĀ ācrimeā,Ā whichĀ wouldĀ be a win-winĀ situationĀ forĀ all,Ā heĀ andĀ HankĀ getĀ theĀ money,Ā hisĀ parentsĀ getĀ theĀ insuranceĀ amount.Ā Ā ButĀ thenĀ everyĀ perfectĀ crime,Ā Ā goesĀ wrong,Ā becauseĀ ofĀ oneĀ Ā stupidĀ blunder,Ā and hereĀ it isĀ HankĀ whoĀ messes it up,Ā when heĀ hiresĀ BobbyĀ Lasorda,Ā anĀ expertĀ crookĀ to carryĀ outĀ theĀ heist.Ā BobbyĀ howeverĀ carries aĀ real gun, insteadĀ ofĀ theĀ toyĀ gun,Ā whichĀ AndyĀ Ā was planningĀ for.Ā AddĀ toĀ it,Ā theĀ oldĀ ladyĀ DorisĀ hasĀ a dayĀ off,Ā which resultsĀ inĀ theirĀ motherĀ Ā handlingĀ theĀ storeĀ thatĀ fatefulĀ day.Ā Ā AndyĀ hadĀ plannedĀ theĀ āperfectĀ heistā,Ā Ā butĀ itĀ hasĀ goneĀ awry,Ā mainlyĀ dueĀ toĀ theĀ blunderĀ madeĀ byĀ Hank,Ā asĀ alsoĀ fate ensuringĀ thatĀ hisĀ motherĀ would be the one in the store, withĀ tragicĀ consequences.
Sorryā aināt gonna pay the bills, Chico!
AndyāsĀ perfectĀ planning,Ā foresightĀ everythingĀ goesĀ forĀ aĀ toss,Ā asĀ itĀ setsĀ into a motion aĀ chain of events,Ā eachĀ threateningĀ toĀ pullĀ theĀ brothersĀ deeperĀ intoĀ anĀ abyss.Ā Ā BobbyāsĀ Ā brotherĀ inĀ law,Ā Dex(Ā MichaelĀ Shannon),Ā beginsĀ toĀ blackmailĀ Ā Hank,Ā toĀ payĀ forĀ hisĀ sister, Chris, whoĀ happens to beĀ BobbyāsĀ widow.Ā Ā AndyāsĀ superiors at work,Ā areĀ nowĀ hotĀ onĀ hisĀ neck,Ā demandingĀ toĀ knowĀ ofĀ Ā theĀ irregularitiesĀ inĀ Ā hisĀ departmentāsĀ accounts.Ā Ā Add toĀ it,Ā theĀ marriageĀ betweenĀ GinaĀ andĀ AndyĀ goesĀ furtherĀ down.Ā AndĀ above allĀ CharlieĀ notĀ satisfiedĀ with theĀ policeĀ investigation,Ā decidesĀ toĀ digĀ deeperĀ onĀ hisĀ own.
WatchingĀ theĀ movieĀ isĀ likeĀ goingĀ alongĀ with theĀ charactersĀ Ā deepĀ intoĀ anĀ abyss, thereĀ appearsĀ to be noĀ respiteĀ fromĀ theĀ unending coldness,Ā theĀ darkness, theĀ despair.Ā EveryĀ actionĀ initiatedĀ byĀ Andy,Ā triggersĀ anotherĀ crisis,Ā thatĀ Ā justĀ dragsĀ himĀ andĀ usĀ deeperĀ down.Ā AndĀ theĀ factĀ thatĀ HankāsĀ Ā hair brainedĀ responsesĀ atĀ times,Ā isĀ Ā aĀ reason,Ā doesĀ notĀ reallyĀ makeĀ thingsĀ Ā better.Ā Ā Ā WeĀ helplesslyĀ watchĀ theĀ livesĀ ofĀ AndyĀ &Ā Hank,Ā hurtlingĀ down and down.Ā Ā Ā ButĀ muchĀ asĀ weĀ wantĀ toĀ empathizeĀ withĀ them,Ā Ā weĀ cannot.Ā UnlikeĀ in DogĀ DayĀ Afternoon,Ā whereĀ weĀ do endĀ upĀ sympathizingĀ withĀ PacinoāsĀ Ā character,Ā hereĀ Ā weĀ feelĀ noĀ remorseĀ forĀ them.Ā Ā WeĀ wantĀ toĀ feelĀ sorryĀ forĀ AndyĀ inĀ theĀ scene, where heĀ breaksĀ downĀ inĀ the carĀ whileĀ drivingĀ withĀ Gina,Ā but thenĀ weĀ knowĀ thatĀ heĀ was one whoĀ hadĀ manipulatedĀ hisĀ brotherĀ intoĀ theĀ situation.Ā Ā WeĀ want to feel sorryĀ forĀ theĀ loserĀ Hank, butĀ then we see thatĀ hisĀ idioticĀ actionsĀ areĀ whatĀ keepsĀ precipitating theĀ crisisĀ furtherĀ andĀ further.
ForĀ theĀ firstĀ timeĀ ever,Ā LumetĀ shootsĀ theĀ entireĀ movieĀ in HD,Ā thatĀ givesĀ the movie, itāsĀ ratherĀ shadowy, dark feel,Ā keepingĀ withĀ theĀ moodĀ ofĀ theĀ plot.Ā Ā Ā To me this movieĀ wouldĀ beĀ oneĀ ofĀ theĀ bestĀ inĀ theĀ NoughtiesĀ ever,Ā matterĀ Ā ofĀ Ā fact,Ā iĀ feelĀ 2007Ā Ā wasĀ theĀ bestĀ everĀ yearĀ in termsĀ ofĀ quality, weĀ hadĀ thisĀ , There Will Be Blood,Ā NoĀ CountryĀ for Old Men, MichaelĀ Clayton.Ā ItĀ isĀ tragic,Ā darkĀ andĀ depressing,Ā butĀ itĀ isĀ notĀ a movieĀ thatĀ wouldĀ leaveĀ yourĀ memories.Ā Ā ItĀ isĀ atĀ oneĀ levelĀ aĀ heistĀ flick,Ā Ā butĀ atĀ aĀ deeperĀ level,Ā itĀ is aĀ fascinatingĀ characterĀ studyĀ setĀ againstĀ Ā aĀ dysfunctionalĀ familyĀ backdrop,Ā andĀ aĀ crimeĀ goneĀ wrongĀ scenario.Ā Ā Ā TheĀ movieĀ isĀ alsoĀ servedĀ byĀ some ofĀ theĀ finestĀ ensembleĀ actingĀ everĀ in a longĀ time.
PhilipĀ SeymourĀ Hoffman,Ā onceĀ againĀ showsĀ hisĀ talent,Ā in aĀ roleĀ that mixesĀ aĀ deviousĀ mind with a vulnerableĀ side.Ā EspeciallyĀ brilliantĀ in theĀ part, whereĀ heĀ breaks downĀ inĀ the car.Ā Ā Ethan Hawke,Ā goingĀ farĀ awayĀ from hisĀ prettyĀ boyĀ image,Ā isĀ firstĀ rate,Ā playingĀ Ā aĀ grungyĀ loser,Ā whoseĀ actions,Ā precipitateĀ a furtherĀ descentĀ intoĀ an abyss.Ā AlbertĀ Finney asĀ usual, packsĀ anĀ emotionalĀ wallop,Ā asĀ theirĀ distraughtĀ father,Ā dealingĀ withĀ his wifeāsĀ death,Ā watchĀ hisĀ expressionsĀ inĀ theĀ finalĀ scene,Ā itĀ hitsĀ you somewhere.Ā Ā Ā MarisaĀ Tomei, though notĀ havingĀ a majorĀ part, neverthelessĀ doesĀ well,Ā andĀ this hasĀ to beĀ oneĀ ofĀ herĀ sexiestĀ onĀ screenĀ performance,Ā maybeĀ after The Wrestler.
I would also recommend you to watch Before Sunrise and Before Sunset of Ethan Hawk. Watch it in same sequence and give some 2-3 months gap between both. (if u haven't already) beautiful true romantic movie.
Nice movie. I like the acting part the most impressive one. Each of the character has performed well. This movie is full of emotions and at times touched my heart.Before the Devil Knows You're Dead Movie
Fine review. I have to admit to not seen this Lumet film. That’s bad of me and I must rectify. Thanks for the heads up.
Well, I came straight to this film and post because I love this film and think it’s vastly underrated and not known by far too many. I previously did a post myself on Sidney Lumet, one of my favorite directors and commented on how he ended his career as he started it, with the highest quality film. AS affecting as 12 Angry Men, by my estimation. Needless to say, I’m very happy to see it get some attention in this event. Great choice!
Aurora
Thank you very much for the kind words. Yes it is one of Lumet’s best movies, very dark,nihilistic, with no let up in the intensity.
A truly dark and disturbing movie with some of the most brilliant performances ever…One of Lumet’s best.